What happens after you send a review
When you send a review on Common Ground, it waits as pending. This means nobody else can see it yet. A moderator then reads it and compares it with our rules for reviews. The moderator either publishes it or rejects it.
A business page only shows published reviews. Only published reviews count toward the score.
Here is what the moderator checks:
- The review is about the reviewer’s own dealings with that business. For example, an order, a booking, a visit or a quote.
- Anything that should not be there is taken out: web links, phone numbers, private information about employees, threats and hateful language.
- It is not one of several reviews by the same person. It is not written by the business’s own staff or by a competitor.
- Each person can review the same business only once every 30 days.
A business can answer any review in public. It cannot edit, hide or remove a review. It cannot pay us to treat a review differently. Bad reviews and good reviews follow exactly the same rules.
How we work out a score
A business’s score is the average of the stars in its published reviews. We add up all the stars and divide by the number of reviews. Then we round to one decimal place. We do not estimate a score or change it by hand, and payment has no effect on it.
We also write every score in words. For example: “4.8 out of 5, from 212 reviews”.
A score gets a label and a color when the business has 5 or more published reviews. Before that, you still see the number, and the label Few reviews next to it. This is because a small number of reviews can change a lot with each new one.
| Label | Score | How it looks |
|---|---|---|
| Very happy | 4.5 to 5.0 | 4.7 out of 5 |
| Happy | 4.0 to 4.4 | 4.2 out of 5 |
| In between | 3.0 to 3.9 | 3.4 out of 5 |
| Unhappy | 2.0 to 2.9 | 2.5 out of 5 |
| Very unhappy | below 2.0 | 1.6 out of 5 |
Separate scores for buying and for services
Each reviewer tells us what they did: bought something, only asked for a price, or had a job done. When enough reviewers have answered, we show two extra scores. One is for buying. The other is for services. A business can do well at one and badly at the other.
Scores for honesty, cost, ease and quality
Reviewers can also give stars for four details: how honest the business was, how fair and clear the cost was, how quick and easy it was, and the quality of what they got. They can say if they paid the price they were quoted, and if they had to pay extra costs they did not expect.
We only show a result for one of these questions after 5 customers have answered it.
The order of businesses in a list
When a list is sorted by stars, we also look at how many reviews each business has. Without this, a business with 3 perfect reviews would come before a business with 40 very good ones.
So we give every business 5 extra, invented reviews of 3.5 stars each. They are not real, and you never see them. Each real review then moves the business closer to its real average. We work out an ordering number like this:
ordering number = (3.5 × 5 + all the stars added together) ÷ (5 + how many reviews there are)
For example, 3 reviews of 5 stars give (17.5 + 15) ÷ (5 + 3) = 4.06. 40 reviews with an average of 4.8 stars give (17.5 + 192) ÷ (5 + 40) = 4.66. The second business comes first.
The ordering number is only used to put lists in order. The score on a business’s page is always the simple average of its reviews.
How reviews reach us
A review can reach us in three ways:
- A customer wrote this review on Common Ground. The customer wrote it and sent it here, on this website.
- A customer wrote this review on the company's own feedback form. The business collected it from one of its own customers and sent it to us. We never accept feedback that the business picked out, changed or paid for.
- From another review website. The customer wrote it on a different review website. We show it exactly as it was published there.
Where business details come from
A listing is the page a business has on our site. It shows the name of the business, where it is, its phone number and its website. We gather these details and check them.
A business may close, or we may no longer be able to confirm its details. Then we hide its listing. We do not delete it, so its reviews are kept.
Claiming a listing is free for the business it belongs to. After claiming, the business can fix wrong details and reply to customers. Its score stays exactly the same.
How to report a review
Below every review there is a link: Ask us to check this review. Use it when you think a review:
- breaks our rules,
- is about the wrong business, or
- is not genuine.
A moderator looks at every report. We may remove the review, keep it, or ask the reviewer for more details. While we look at a report, the review stays on the page.